In game barbershop for things like hairstyles, hair color, accessories.

Permanent dye (seriously, it would get expensive enough just to dye each new piece of equipment I got as I leveled--why would I want to have to dye it more than once?).

Mailboxes. Because I don't like having to go to the 'bank' just to check my mail (and it took me two hours to figure out this game didn't have them. Yes, I'm dumb. Sue me. ;) ).

Crafting that levels with your exp leveling if you're willing to put the work into it. As it is now, it's a time and money sink for very little gain that most people despise.

More dark haired/red haired choices on ALL races in the creation screens.

The ability to choose hair style separately from horn/ear/tail changes on certain races.

The ability to choose different hair colors for the Elin hairstyles/tails and ears (I want to play a long haired 'Siamese' cat girl, thanks).

The ability to bind my movement 'keys' to my mouse so that I can clear up the keyboard for my other key binds for combat. Left hand=combat, right hand=move for me. It would be nice to be able to adjust the game keys accordingly.

Cookies. Or chocolate. I'm good with either.

With regard to chocolate...

Black Elins. Is a skinshade darker than "lightly toasted at Coney Island" unfeasible compared to the Trix Are For Kids (TM) hair job the characters got at Shaniqua's Hair Care, Tire Salon & Ice Cream Parlor?

Karaoke in Castanica.

More expansive lore that you can actually build a character off of. I grant that I haven't spent more than a few hours investigating the lore of this game but it all seems very vague and self conflicting. While I would like to RP this game just really does not at all feel conducive to the art.

Other than that? Nit picks I don't remember until I come across them, maybe I'll add them later.