Nice to see that some folks are capable of being civil at least... FYI I do like your Idea better then the original way at least...
I doubt however that it will sway their decision... Good luck in your efforts though...
The problem with the current system is that now enchanting is more of a necessity to bring your gear up to par, not to make it superior. The system may just as well +12 everything upon identification with the scrolls costing 50x as much as they do now.
But it does have two positives... and yes there are positives:
PvE content can be more reliably built/westernized with the assumption everyone will have +12 gear.
PvP is much more skill based. If one can not be bothered to get to +12, they deserve to get stomped by those that do. Losing enchant fodder is hardly worth calling a risk compared to losing an enchantment level.
Might I ask why the thread title calls this "free"?
I didn't know needing many mats was free, or is there an I WIN button on the enchant window?
Does OP realize that you can still fail an enchant? The only thing removed was the chance of it decreasing by 1.