Quote: Zeroz on 04/24/2012, 03:02 PM

Quote: xFervid on 04/24/2012, 01:30 PM

You had to fend off 3 crabs at once? Is that even possible, because any time three BAMs are aggro'd, one immediately resets. Anyway, that's obviously not the issue here. Zeroz may have some valid points, but the fact of the matter is that the guild owners are not around to babysit anyone. Instead of presenting a "warning" to the community about some bad apples, it would have been a lot more professional of you to contact someone in game first about this. The website is listed on the main page, if you were so inclined to discuss this misunderstanding it probably could have been done on better terms.

That's just IMO of course and everyone is entitled to their own. I know that in the school I work at, when someone does something wrong, we isolate the problem and contact the parents, we wouldn't make a big scene and label the whole school as a trouble school. Every single guild on this server is going to have "a few bad apples" in it. Grass isn't always greener on the other side. Regardless, this seems like a pretty trivial issue to discuss in a thread like this.

Like I said

1) I've been out of the loop of these things, and I was under the impression that the guild itself was questionable (two groups from the same guilds, trying to grief others, at a size of 80, that's 1/8th of the guild -to be fair, the two group could have overlap of the same members since they come at different times- so you'd have to forgive me if I already have an unfavourable view :P), Silph have proven otherwise thus far. Even in the case that I DID post it in the right spot, it would've been a game of "he said she said" that would've been a lost cause (refer to Lalaru's replies). Even here, it would've been another case of "he said she said" if Lalaru wasn't so clear about her (and hope not the guild's) intention with her initial reply.

2) We did indeed had the 3 crabs on us unless of course it was their lancer still trying to get us killed by circling that 3rd into us to do collateral damage (we had to kill them all in either case). We did not get credit for 1 of the crabs when we killed them all, the crab that the other group that got wiped did give us credit, you don't need much thinking when there have been 3 groups of ppls there the entire time and one got wipe to find out who that last crab belonged to (the mystic-lancer pairs left everyone alone while they camped the top of the hill)

3) I already apologized for posting in the wrong spot (please read everything, unless my english is failing me somehow, in that case, please correct me ><). There's no "misunderstanding" at all as Lalaru's reply was pretty clear on dirty plays and KS (how does that apply? Thought KS only applies on games that register the kill on last hit, unless the meaning changed while I was away). It also seems like she's in a position of some power within the guild, so I won't say this doesn't warrant a warning. The primary reason I even apologized in the first place was because Silph was reasonable about PM and stuff, even though it was assume this was a bash at the guild and I know this is kind of an uncomfortable position to be in.

You are right we shouldn't be discussing it in a thread like this, but we are already here and your post made me have to clarify some stuff ><

Okay let me begin with this, LunarSky eat (edited) like you for breakfast every morning.

Second of all, We Might be a guild full of trolls but we would Never Ever grief someone in such a lowly way on purpose. We Have An Ethic, we trolls but we do not Grief. I think that pretty much replies to all your lowly complains on my behavior, If I ever happened to attack the same mob you were attacking, you definitely have a great deal of responsibility in this.

If you thought even 1 second that making such assumption on a guild especially this 1 would work because we roll on PVE, you're dead wrong. You should try this on Celestial Hills and roll there while you're at it. If you want to reply to this post, know that it won't get better for you.

Also Technokarate, you should take responsability on what you said and stop acting like if it was a fun joke, what you said is like betraying our trust in you even before you joined and is not to be laughed at.

thanks for bumping our thread! U ROCK!